The History Of Our Soil

•


“The History of Our Soil” is an interactive exhibit designed by CODES Scholars Alejandra Beltrán and Zachary Tobias in collaboration with the Missouri Botanical Garden (MOBOT) between 2023 and 2025. Archival documents preserved at MOBOT reveal that Henry Shaw, the garden’s founder, enslaved individuals whose labor was essential to the development of the Missouri Botanical Garden. Research conducted in the archives has uncovered the names of several people enslaved by Shaw. However, many of the experiences and contributions of those who lived and worked on the land that would later become one of St. Louis’s most recognized institutions remain incomplete or absent from the historical record.

“The History of Our Soil” shares the fragments of information that are known about Peach, Juliette, Bridget, Lewis, Coss, Sally, Jeremy, Tabitha, Joseph, Sarah, Jim Kennerly, Esther and her children, Maria, Mary Ann, and Rody. These details encourage visitors to consider whose stories are remembered, whose stories are missing, and how confronting the past can help build a more honest and inclusive future. The team planned for the exhibit to be interwoven throughout the rooms of Henry Shaw’s Tower Grove House.

The team envisioned the exhibit as an interactive experience embedded within Tower Grove House, which is located on MOBOT’s grounds. Grounded in principles of reparative justice, the exhibit draws from the Henry Shaw Papers, records preserved by the garden, and additional archival research. Through these materials, the project demonstrates how the garden’s beauty developed alongside histories of forced labor and displacement.

Beltrán and Tobias worked on the project with other CODES Scholars on Bryan Jack’s research team throughout 2023, and they presented their concept to MOBOT in fall 2024. With support from a National Park Service grant in 2025, MOBOT was able to build upon their work and install the completed interactive exhibit in Tower Grove House in spring 2026. This story outlines the process Beltrán and Tobias followed to develop, refine, and complete the project.

The 2027 class of CODES Scholars partners with the Missouri Botanical Garden through the theme of reparative justice, an approach that centers healing, accountability, and the repair of past harms. Drawing on MOBOT’s archives and Henry Shaw’s papers, this cohort explored how the Garden’s history can be shared with greater honesty and care. Working alongside Michelle Bonner, Robbie Hart, and Andrew Colligan, CODES Scholars examined the institution’s history of enslavement, the erasure of Black and Brown communities connected to Shaw Nature Reserve, and the Indigenous knowledge and cultural context reflected in Herbarium specimens. Through this work, the project helps MOBOT tell these stories with intentionality and sensitivity while creating more meaningful ways for visitors to engage with them.

“The History of Our Soil” seeks to create an accessible public-history experience that helps visitors better understand the history of enslavement connected to the Missouri Botanical Garden. Through archival materials and guided interpretation, the project encourages visitors to develop a deeper relationship with the garden, its history, and the stories that have not always been fully represented within its institutional memory.

The labor of enslaved African Americans was connected to Henry Shaw’s properties, including the land and buildings that later became part of the Missouri Botanical Garden. Although this labor contributed to the maintenance and development of these properties, the experiences and identities of enslaved individuals have often received limited attention in traditional historical accounts.

This history is important because the development of St. Louis was shaped by enslavement, Indigenous displacement, and unequal systems of power. By bringing these connections into public view, the project asks visitors to consider whose stories have been preserved, whose stories have been overlooked, and why those absences matter.

Developing this project required examining a large volume of archival material, incomplete records, and historical connections that were not always easy to trace. In some cases, documents provided only limited information about the people connected to Shaw’s properties.

These gaps became an important part of the research process. They demonstrated how historical records can preserve certain perspectives while leaving others incomplete. The project team had to carefully consider what information could be included, how it could be presented clearly, and how to avoid oversimplifying complex and difficult histories.

This project is guided by reparative justice through its focus on truth-telling, accountability, and public access. Reparative justice encourages institutions to recognize past harms and consider how they can respond in responsible and meaningful ways.

By placing archival materials in a public setting, “The History of Our Soil” creates an opportunity for visitors to engage with histories that may otherwise remain distant or unseen. The project does not treat the Garden as separate from its past but instead encourages a fuller understanding of the people, systems, and histories connected to it.

The interactive learning pathway format is especially appropriate because it asks participants to do more than observe. They must move through the space, read, interpret, and reflect. This shift from passive viewing to active engagement matters because it can have a cognitive impact. It encourages participants to understand the Garden not as a neutral backdrop but as a place tied to histories of enslavement, power, and exclusion. By centering these histories, the project resists the tendency to let beauty erase violence or allow institutions to tell only the most comfortable version of their past.

The project also supports reparative justice by increasing access. Each station provides a short, readable entry point into the historical material, while the QR code gives participants access to the complete archival document. This structure respects different levels of engagement. Some visitors may pause for a brief encounter, while others may want to explore the archives more deeply. Either way, the project creates a path toward historical visibility and reflection, which is one meaningful step in reparative work.

Across two years of research, the project team used the following guiding questions to plan the exhibit:

  1. Where could the team locate reliable information about Shaw, enslavement, and the individuals connected to his estate? Which archives, institutions, databases, and collections could serve as the primary sources for gathering these materials?
  2. To what extent were these materials accessible to the public, and what barriers limited access?
  3. How could this history be presented in a way that honors enslaved individuals and accurately addresses Shaw’s role in enslavement while still acknowledging his significance to the history of St. Louis?
  4. What communication methods would most effectively convey this information to Garden visitors in an accessible, thoughtful, and respectful manner?
  5. How could visuals, movement through physical space, and digital access points strengthen visitor engagement with this history?

The project team conducted archival research in collaboration with staff members at the Missouri Botanical Garden (MOBOT). Working with Andrew Colligan, the team examined primary-source materials connected to Henry Shaw and the history of the Garden.

The researchers reviewed handwritten documents, financial records such as bills of sale, property records, and census materials from MOBOT’s archival collection. Their research focused not only on what they were able to find in the archives but also on what was missing or did not fully fit into the larger historical narrative.

Many of the records provided limited information about workers, enslaved individuals, and Indigenous communities connected to these spaces. These gaps became an important part of the research because they demonstrated how people and experiences can be erased or overlooked in historical records. By paying attention to both the evidence that exists and the information that is missing, the project team sought to build a fuller and more honest understanding of the history connected to Henry Shaw and the Garden.

Reliable information about Henry Shaw, enslavement, and individuals connected to his properties can be found primarily in the Missouri Botanical Garden Archives, including the Henry Shaw Papers and institutional records. This archival evidence can be supplemented by census schedules, property records, newspapers, and local or state historical collections that provide broader context for nineteenth-century St. Louis.

The most important collection for this project is MOBOT’s Henry Shaw Papers, along with Garden records and digitized historical materials. These sources preserve records connected to Shaw’s personal, financial, and property-related activities, making them essential for tracing connections between Shaw, his estate, and enslavement. Primary sources include bills of sale, financial receipts, correspondence, property records, census schedules, and newspaper advertisements. Records such as Shaw’s reward advertisement for Sarah and her son, documents connected to Esther, and receipts concerning James and Sally provide direct evidence of his relationship to people he enslaved.

Many records still require archival research, staff guidance, or experience reading nineteenth-century handwriting and terminology. Another major barrier is the archive itself: records often preserve financial transactions or property details while providing limited information about the lives, families, and experiences of enslaved people. These absences are not simply missing details; they are part of what the project asks visitors to notice.

This history should be presented with accuracy, care, and respect for the people whose lives appear in the records. The project centers available names, documents, and individual stories while clearly recognizing the limits of the archive. Rather than separating Henry Shaw’s contributions to St. Louis from his involvement in enslavement, the project presents both as part of a fuller historical account. This approach allows visitors to understand the Garden’s legacy with greater honesty and context.

Visuals, movement, and digital access help turn archival research into an active learning experience. As visitors move through the stations, they can connect individual documents to a larger story about land, labor, memory, and institutional history. QR codes provide access to full archival materials for visitors who want to explore further, while shorter summaries make the project accessible to those encountering this history for the first time. Together, the physical pathway and digital resources create space for both learning and reflection.

(List each of the documents we gathered. Include description of the document, why the specific doc was important and how it contributed to the exhibit, and the link to the online version) 

“The History of Our Soil” is a self-guided interactive learning pathway located in and around Henry Shaw’s Tower Grove House at the Missouri Botanical Garden. The pathway uses archival research, visual interpretation, and physical movement through the space to introduce visitors to histories of enslavement connected to Henry Shaw, his properties, and the development of the Garden. The experience is designed as a sequence of short, connected encounters. Rather than presenting visitors with one large display, it breaks the history into focused moments that are easier to understand, explore, and reflect on.

The pathway begins with an introductory station in Tower Grove House that provides context for the project and explains how visitors can move through the experience. The stations guide visitors through individual records and broader themes, including enslavement, labor, land, memory, and historical absence. Each station contributes to a larger narrative, allowing visitors to connect separate documents and stories over the course of the pathway. The experience concludes with a final reflection station in Tower Grove House. This closing point invites visitors to consider how the history they encountered changes their understanding of the Garden and its place in St. Louis history.

The learning pathway combines concise on-site interpretation with optional digital exploration. Visitors can engage with the essential information at each station or use the QR codes to access full archival materials and continue learning at their own pace. The stations are designed with readable text, clear visual organization, and consistent placement of information. This format supports visitors with different levels of historical knowledge and allows the experience to remain accessible without simplifying the complexity of the history.

Each Station includes the following elements:

ComponentDescription
A Focused TitleIntroduces the person, document, place, or question at the center of the station.
Historical NarrativeProvides essential context in accessible language without overwhelming the visitor.
Archival VisualFeatures a document excerpt, historical image, map, or related visual material that connects visitors directly to the historical record.
Reflection PromptEncourages visitors to pause and consider what the record reveals, what may be missing, and why the history matters.
QR codeConnects visitors to full documents, transcriptions, source information, and additional historical context.

Working on “The History of Our Soil” demonstrated to the project team that difficult histories cannot be approached with simple answers. Through their research, the team learned that archives can reveal important connections while also leaving many questions unanswered. This process emphasized the importance of patience, care, and honesty when working with stories that have too often been overlooked.

The lessons gained through this project shaped more than the team’s understanding of the Garden’s history. They also shaped Beltrán and Tobias’s development as CODES Scholars by reminding them that meaningful community work requires listening, collaboration, and a willingness to confront the past with humility. The project team hopes this pathway encourages visitors to look more closely at the Garden, reflect on the stories connected to it, and carry that curiosity beyond the experience.


Authors